New Jersey has real trout water. The South Branch of the Raritan through Ken Lockwood Gorge, the Musconetcong, the Big Flatbrook, and the Pequest are the names you hear most. The New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife stocks many of these streams, and the hatches here are good.
Spring is the big season. Blue Quills, Quill Gordons, and Hendricksons come off in April. March Browns and Sulphurs follow on rivers like the Musky. Blue-winged Olives show up in the colder months and again in late spring. Five flies cover most of it.
Ranked by versatility across rivers, seasons, and trout species.
Pattern #1
Sizes#14 – #16
ColorsTan, Gray
SeasonApril – May
TechniqueDead drift, parachute dun
April is mayfly month on North Jersey streams. Blue Quills, Quill Gordons, and Hendricksons are the main hatches, and anglers who fish them usually carry a few of each in sizes 14 and 16. A Parachute Hendrickson stands in for the group when you only have room for one.
Hatches tend to start around midday and can run into the afternoon, especially on cold, damp, overcast days. Local guides like parachute-wing patterns for the duns.
Pro Tip: Carry a few emergers and a spent-wing pattern too. Spent wings work for spinners later in the day, and also before a hatch starts or after it ends.
Pattern #2
Sizes#18 – #22
ColorsOlive, Gray
SeasonLate winter – June
TechniqueDead drift, emerger dropper
Blue-winged Olives are probably the most important hatch on the Big Flatbrook. They often come off from late winter through April and again in late May and early June. They also show up on the South Branch of the Raritan from May into mid June.
Cloudy, drizzly days are when they tend to hatch best. A small parachute BWO gives trout a clear, low-riding target.
Pro Tip: Fish a BWO emerger as a dropper behind the dun. Trout in slow, clear water often take the emerger first.
Pattern #3
Sizes#14 – #18
ColorsNatural, Copper bead
SeasonYear-round
TechniqueIndicator nymphing, tight-line
When nothing is hatching, trout are still eating nymphs. The Pheasant Tail covers mayfly nymphs of all kinds, and South Branch guides note that smaller flies generally do best in the colder months.
It also works as the lower fly under a dry on spring mornings, before the first duns show up.
Pro Tip: In cold, low water, go smaller and lighter. A #18 unweighted version under a small indicator is often better than a heavy bead.