Get the FlyFishFinder app

Free on iPhone and Android.

Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play
New York fly fishing

Oatka Creek

Fly fishing Oatka Creek near Caledonia and Le Roy, New York, a well known brown trout stream.

  • 84 miRiver length
  • 1Game fish
  • 47Access points
Want to see the top 10 fishable rivers near you right now? Check them free
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play
In the FlyFishFinder app Oatka Creek Every access point, mapped Today's top 10 rivers near you Live flows from nearby gages Today's rating Premium Open in the app

About Oatka Creek

Oatka Creek is a classic western New York brown trout stream. It flows through Genesee and Wyoming counties and is best known around Caledonia and Le Roy, where the Caledonia fish hatchery has a long history.

The water is Gold Medal, with wild and stocked brown trout. The stretch from Caledonia to Le Roy sees the most pressure and has a public fishing area managed by the DEC with parking and trails. Route 19 runs alongside much of it, with bridge crossings that make access easy.

Spring brings the best hatches. Hendrickson, Grannom, Sulphur and Early Black Stonefly come along, and Trico and Isonychia show later. Fall is a good time for larger browns.

Most people wade. The creek is small enough to fish with a short rod. Public access and rules vary by section, so check the DEC regulations and posted signs.

Fish you'll catch

Tap a fish to see every New York river that holds it.

Hatching in November

What's on the water in the Southwestern Lake Ontario watershed this month, and the fly to match.

Fall BWO
Other
#18-20, Sparkle Dun
44–56°F
All 12 hatches this year
Early Black Stonefly
Stonefly
#16-18, Black Elk Hair
36–50°F
Blue-Winged Olive
Mayfly
#18-22, CDC Emerger
44–58°F
Hendrickson
Mayfly
#12-14, Comparadun
48–58°F
Brown Drake
Mayfly
#10-12, Brown Drake
55–65°F
Grannom
Caddis
#14-16, Elk Hair Caddis
48–58°F
Hex / Giant Mayfly
Mayfly
#4-6, Hex Paradrake
62–72°F
Michigan Caddis
Caddis
#14, Sparkle Pupa
58–70°F
Sulphur
Mayfly
#16-18, Parachute Sulphur
55–68°F
Trico
Mayfly
#22-26, Trico Poly Wing
60–72°F
Flying Ant
Terrestrial
#16-18, Fur Ant
64–76°F
Isonychia
Mayfly
#10-12, Slate Drake
58–68°F
Fall BWO
Other
#18-20, Sparkle Dun
44–56°F

Light bars show the season and dark bars the peak. The ringed month is this month.

Tips for fishing Oatka Creek

  • Start at the public fishing area

    The DEC area between Caledonia and Le Roy has parking and trails and is easy to find.

  • Fish early in spring

    Hatches get going in April and carry on into June. Hendrickson and Sulphur are good bets.

  • Try fall for bigger fish

    Browns get more active as the water cools. Streamers can pay off.

  • Respect private land

    Not every mile has public fishing rights. Stay on marked access and ask permission where needed.

  • Save your access spots

    The FlyFishFinder app maps access points so you can find the public sections quickly.

Every access point on Oatka Creek, in your pocket.

  • 47 mapped access points, with parking and put-ins
  • Today's Fishability score, so you fish the day that lines up
  • 7-day flow and water-temp trends for every gauge on the river
Get the free app

Oatka Creek FAQ

What is the best time to fly fish Oatka Creek?

Spring and fall. Spring is best for hatches, and fall for larger browns.

Where can I fish Oatka Creek near Le Roy?

The Caledonia to Le Roy stretch is the most popular, with a DEC public fishing area.

Can you wade Oatka Creek?

Yes, wading is the standard way to fish it.

What flies work on Oatka Creek?

Pheasant Tail and Prince nymphs, Hendrickson dries, Elk Hair Caddis and small streamers. The FlyFishFinder app shows what is working today.

What fish are in Oatka Creek?

Brown trout, both wild and stocked.

Are there special rules on Oatka Creek?

Yes, special regulations apply. Check the current New York DEC guide.

Get the free app